25 Best Butcher Shops in West Virginia (2025 Guide)

Crestview Meat Market is highly regarded for its quality meats and excellent customer service. It offers a wide variety of fresh cuts at fair prices, with friendly staff working hard to serve numerous customers. Despite occasional issues like poorly cut items or unexpected price discrepancies, the overall experience is overwhelmingly positive. Its remodeled space adds to the pleasant atmosphere and continues to attract regulars who value its commitment to delivering top-notch meats and maintaining a welcoming environment.

Farmer's Daughter Market & Butcher has earned a reputation as one of the best places for burgers in its region, with exceptional quality meats and a wide range of products including pork chops and bacon that are widely praised by customers. The establishment offers an excellent dining experience with attentive staff who provide knowledgeable recommendations. Its burgers have consistently received top ratings, showcasing both their unique appeal and delicious taste, making it an essential stop for food enthusiasts in the area. Despite some minor drawbacks like limited menu options, the overall experience at Farmer's Daughter Market & Butcher is overwhelmingly positive, driving customers back time and again for its exceptional quality and friendliness.

Miklas Meat Market is widely praised for its exceptional selection and quality meats, coupled with excellent customer service. Customers appreciate the wide range of options including specialty items, and find the staff to be very friendly and efficient, often going above and beyond. Despite occasional frustrations related to management behavior towards employees, Miklas consistently stands out as a top choice in Wheeling for high-quality meat products, earning multiple 5-star reviews over several years.

D & D Meats is consistently praised for its fantastic service and wide selection of fresh meats, attracting customers with their excellent prices and friendly staff. Known for their inviting aroma upon entry, the store offers a diverse range of items including homemade candies and various sides, catering to local tastes and preferences. Customers often return for both the quality meat and the positive experiences they have there, highlighting D & D Meats as one of the best places in town for fresh meats and additional culinary delights.

19th Street Meat Market is celebrated for its excellent service and quality meats. Customers appreciate the friendly atmosphere where they can find a variety of homemade salads, desserts, and deli items. The market offers great products at good prices, and customers have reported consistency over many years, with some having been regulars for several years. Despite occasional hiccups like using store-bought meat in certain cases, overall customer satisfaction is high, leading to multiple 5-star ratings from repeat visits.

Village Butcher and Market is consistently praised for its delicious burgers, which are often considered the best in town. The establishment offers an extensive selection of meat cuts suitable for takeout or in-house dining. Customers appreciate both the fast service and the impressive interior, featuring a butcher shop atmosphere with multiple amenities like refrigerated displays and drink coolers. Despite occasional minor issues such as ordering errors, the overall experience is consistently positive due to the exceptional quality of their offerings.

Hilltop Fresh Meat Market is widely praised for its exceptional quality meats and friendly service. Customers appreciate the great prices, fresh products, and knowledgeable staff who provide detailed butcher instructions. Despite minor issues with filet mignon texture in ground beef, most reviews highlight consistent excellence in meat selection and customer satisfaction. The market's commitment to local support and quality ensures it remains a trusted destination for both regulars and newcomers alike.

Hydes Meat Packing receives consistently high praise for its fresh and high-quality meat offerings. Customers appreciate the friendly staff who are knowledgeable about various cuts and can cater to specific preferences. Despite occasional disappointments, the overwhelming majority of reviews highlight the establishment's commitment to providing excellent service and top-notch meats at reasonable prices. Many customers have established long-term relationships with the business, driving significant distances just to access their products.

Johnnies Fresh Meats stands out among other meat markets with its consistently high-quality meats that stand up to any grocery store offering. The friendly staff and excellent customer service make every visit memorable, whether for fresh pork chops, perfectly juicy steaks, or even veggie burgers catering to all dietary needs. Its convenient location near major highways makes it easy for people to stock their pantries without much hassle. Johnnies not only delights in providing fresh meat but also ensures customers get the best value with reasonable prices and exceptional selection across various categories including cheeses and sandwiches.

Butcher Block stands out with its consistently excellent meat cuts and friendly service, appealing to both regulars who have been loyal customers for decades and newcomers looking for the best steaks in the area. Known locally since long before it became a staple of the community, Ralph and Janet take pride in ensuring every cut is top-notch, whether for casual dining or special occasions like Memorial services. Their dedication to quality meats has earned them numerous 5-star reviews, making Butcher Block a go-to choice for anyone seeking superior craftsmanship from a dedicated butcher shop.

Joe Leadmon Meat Shop is renowned for offering top-quality meat and excellent service at reasonable prices. Customers have been praising the shop since its establishment, with some customers having relied on them for over a decade. The meats are often described as fresh and of superior quality, making it clear that Joe Leadmon maintains high standards in both quality and customer satisfaction. Despite occasional issues with product freshness, the overall reputation remains extremely positive among repeat customers.

Wayne's Country Fresh Meats stands out with consistently excellent service and quality meats across various reviews dating back for years. The store maintains cleanliness and freshness while offering great prices on both lunch meat and fresh burgers. Friendly staff who are knowledgeable about their products further enhance the overall experience, making it a popular choice among customers looking for reliable local meat sourcing solutions.

Call's Meat Market is known for its exceptional meats and friendly service. Customers appreciate the high-quality offerings from local farms and the knowledgeable staff who ensure satisfaction with their selection of pork, chicken, beef, and buffalo cuts. Despite occasionally experiencing issues with reservations not being available when customers arrive, the overall experience remains highly positive, earning consistent 5-star ratings. The store's commitment to freshness and quality has made it a preferred destination for many in the area, whether they're local or visiting from elsewhere.

Hill Country Meats, LLC seems to be highly regarded by customers for its top-notch quality meats and exceptional customer service. Known for being extremely clean with a wide variety of offerings including custom cuts, jerky, sausage, bacon, and bologna, Leonard takes pride in his work and goes out of his way to assist customers. Offering excellent service at reasonable prices, this family-owned business has garnered numerous 5-star reviews over the years, making it a popular choice for both locals and those traveling from afar who appreciate locally sourced, high-quality meats.

The Butcher Shop has earned consistent five-star ratings from customers who praise its exceptional meat cuts and knowledgeable staff. Not only does it offer top-quality meats sourced locally, but it also provides an extensive selection of spices and other food items for charcuterie boards or further culinary creations. Despite a minor hiccup with a missed reservation, the overall experience was overwhelmingly positive, making it worth visiting for both novice and seasoned cooks alike. Its friendly environment and reliable service make it stand out in a competitive market, ensuring a memorable shopping experience and satisfying meal outcomes for customers.

Farmers Meats & Deli, LLC seems to be a highly regarded local business with consistently positive feedback from customers who appreciate the friendly service, great selection of meats and deli items, reasonable prices, and overall excellent experience. Despite some past issues highlighted by one review, which included expired meat, delayed order fulfillment, lack of weight labels for packages, and no confirmation before shipping orders, the majority of reviews indicate that this establishment offers high-quality products at fair prices with a welcoming atmosphere. Customers consistently praise its professionalism, friendliness, and helpful staff, suggesting it has become a new favorite among those seeking fresh meats in their area.

Grazer's Market stands out among other food establishments for its delightful array of meats and sandwiches. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients used in their creations, with many touting how generous they are with deli meat. The market also offers an impressive selection of cheeses, local honey, and homemade chocolate chip cookies that exceed expectations. Despite being a bit pricey, customers find it worth the investment due to the quality and authenticity of the products.

Swift Level Fine Meats is highly regarded for its premium quality meats and exceptional customer service. From expertly cut steaks to fresh seafood brought in regularly, the selection meets high standards. Despite some issues with butchery and inconsistent freshness of frozen options, most customers find it worth the price due to locally sourced ingredients. The store's vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff make for a delightful experience that encourages return visits.

Troyer's Quality Meats is highly praised for its exceptional service and quality products. Customers appreciate the friendly atmosphere, professional staff who deliver on their promises of fresh cuts and fair pricing. The facility is clean and well-organized, making customer choices straightforward and comfortable. Their extra sage sausage stands out as a standout product, earning them multiple 5-star ratings over the years.

Syrews Custom Butchering received mixed reviews with some customers giving it high ratings for their service and quality, such as 5 stars from customers who appreciated the attention to detail in meat preparation and friendliness of staff. However, there were also negative comments regarding punctuality and customer satisfaction issues, like a heifer getting hung for more days than expected leading to missing parts on the returned steers. Despite these challenges, overall, Syrews Custom Butchering maintained positive feedback from customers who continued to use their services or recommended them to others based on their consistent excellent service and quality.

S&J Custom Meats has built an impressive reputation over the years for its quality service and fair prices. Customers appreciate the friendly and professional approach of the owners, who ensure timely delivery and proper packaging of processed meats. Despite some past dissatisfaction with new management, the establishment continues to offer excellent services that have consistently received high ratings from customers who trust S&J for their hunting needs.

K & L Processing has consistently received high ratings from customers who appreciate the quality of their meat products and services. Not only are they praised for their quick service and fair pricing, but also for their attentive and friendly staff. Despite occasional minor issues like receiving paper packaging instead of vacuum sealed items, most customers still found them to be top-notch in their area. The company's dedication is evident, with owners known for being honest and offering great prices, which further contributes to their reputation as one of the best meat processing companies available.

Butchers Black Angus offers consistently fresh meat cuts including ground beef and various types of chops, steaks, chicken salads, and hot dogs that cater to different dietary needs. The store also features an impressive selection of fruits, vegetables, canned goods, dry goods, assorted sodas, and juices, along with a great variety of locally sourced produce. With convenient parking and close proximity to eateries, gas stations, and the main road, it is easily accessible. However, there have been instances where customer service could be improved, leading some to rate their experience as below average. Despite this, its reputation for providing high-quality meats has kept many customers returning over time.