25 Best Butcher Shops in Vermont (2025 Guide)

Williston Meat & Fish Market is highly regarded for its exceptional quality in meats and seafood, consistently praised for the excellent service provided by their friendly and knowledgeable staff. The store offers an impressive selection of high-quality foods and drinks, which are always fresh and plentiful, contributing to its popularity among customers who appreciate the clean and well-organized environment. Despite a few instances where customer information might not have been accurately conveyed initially, Williston Meat & Fish Market consistently delivers superior customer service, ensuring that their reputation as one of the best in the area remains strong.

Brownsville Butcher & Pantry offers an extensive selection for both food enthusiasts and casual shoppers with its small grocery section including top-quality meats at reasonable prices. The café features gourmet coffee, local draft beers, and bistro-style meals that rival sit-down restaurants. Whether it's the homemade sausages or house-made sauces, customers appreciate the fresh ingredients sourced locally. A must-visit for those seeking exceptional dining experiences paired with meticulously prepared groceries in a welcoming atmosphere.

Bob's Meat Market stands out as an exceptional establishment in the local market scene. Known for its superb selection of quality meats and deli choices, it offers customers fresh roast beef made in-house without any additives or preservatives. The staff is notably friendly, often greeted with enthusiasm by owner Rob himself, creating a warm atmosphere that caters not only to regulars but also first-time visitors alike. Despite occasional lapses such as the service issue reported, Bob's continues to be celebrated for its commitment to supporting local businesses and offering healthy options free from industrial manipulations.

Besserys Butcher Shoppe offers consistently excellent food and service with friendly staff who prioritize customer satisfaction. Despite some reviews mentioning issues or inefficiencies, the majority of customers highly recommend its grilled chicken sandwiches, Philly cheesesteak subs, and other classic dishes at reasonable prices. The store also takes pride in making custom orders even when time is short, showcasing a commitment to meeting customers' needs efficiently. However, there have been instances where staff policies led to customer dissatisfaction or operational challenges that need addressing for a perfect dining experience.

Libbey's Meat Market stands out with its extensive selection and high-quality meats, fresh from the bone to the perfectly smoked items right off the smoker. The friendly staff provides excellent customer service across various products including artisan cheeses, sauces, pasta, and more. Known for its clean, organized interior and welcoming atmosphere, it feels like a quintessential small town market where customers always look forward to visiting.

Village Butcher Shop is highly regarded for its excellent deli sandwiches and fresh meats. The friendly staff provides helpful recommendations and goes out of their way to accommodate customers. It's not just about the food; the charming atmosphere and variety of products make it a favorite spot, especially among those visiting Woodstock, Vermont. Whether stopping by for lunch or bringing home a cut of meat, Village Butcher Shop consistently offers great choices.

Roma's Butchery is praised for its exceptional selection of locally sourced meats and sausages, coupled with an inviting atmosphere in a historic setting. The food experience is consistently memorable, whether it's the bacon smashburger or the loaded tots, making it stand out among other restaurants. Staff interactions enhance the dining experience, and the array of baked goods further adds to its charm, solidifying its recommendation as one of the best places for both butchery and casual dining in the area.

The Butchery is highly regarded for its exceptional selection and preparation of meats and seafood, offering both local favorites and high-quality imported items. Customers appreciate the friendly service provided by their dedicated staff, who offer helpful advice on cooking techniques. Despite occasional issues with pricing and presentation, The Butchery consistently delivers excellent value and quality products that keep customers coming back.

The Vermont Butcher Shop garners consistently high praise for its top-quality meats and cheeses. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable staff who help select cuts best suited for cooking success. The store's selection is often highlighted despite being limited at certain times of day, showcasing variety among local and specialty products. Regulars find it worth making a special trip from other parts of Vermont to visit this exceptional butcher shop.

Brault's Meat Market & Slaughterhouse has garnered consistently high praise across various reviews. Known for its exceptional quality meat and outstanding customer service, the establishment is beloved by locals and visitors alike for its artisanal cuts and custom services. Not only does it offer an extensive range of meats including beef, pork, and venison, but Brault's also excels in preparing their products to exacting standards. The friendly staff ensures every visit feels personal and welcoming, with a commitment to humane treatment of animals from farm to table.

Wallingford Locker stands out as an exceptional local butcher shop with an old-school charm that appeals to both locals and visitors alike. Customers praise its wide variety of fresh and aged meats, including specialty items like cob-smoked bacon and aged cheddar cheese, which are often praised for their superior taste compared to supermarket alternatives. The friendly staff ensure customers get the best cuts and offer knowledgeable advice on selecting meat, making it a favorite destination for those in search of high-quality, authentic Vermont products.

Morgan Brook Farm - Butcher Barn stands out for its exceptional customer service and knowledgeable staff who offer an impressive array of fresh and high-quality local meats. The store’s commitment to freshness is evident in the premium Wagyu steaks and sausages, complemented by traditional options that cater to diverse tastes. Its clean and inviting atmosphere ensures a pleasant shopping experience while enjoying the captivating view from the butchering kitchen area. Customers frequently return for their exceptional steak selections and personalized services, making it an invaluable addition to local dining experiences.

Shelburne Meat & Fish Market seems to be a place with consistently high ratings across various aspects. Known for its exceptional quality meats and fresh seafood selections, customers appreciate the friendly service and helpful staff, though there have been instances of poor customer service leading some patrons to question their practices. Despite pricing higher than many other markets or stores, these are often justified by the remarkable quality and range of products available, including local suppliers and gourmet condiments. The market has also established a reputation for accommodating unique requests and maintaining traditions, which resonates with both locals and frequent visitors alike.

Orange Custom Game Processing is renowned for its top-notch meat and seafood offerings. Customers appreciate the fresh, high-quality products, including unique items like heart-shaped steaks on Valentine's Day. The shop maintains an immaculate cleanliness, and the staff are knowledgeable and friendly. Regulars have enjoyed their selection of jerky and custom meat processing services, making it a favorite among customers for its quality and service.

Royal Butcher stands out for its exceptional customer service and professionalism from the initial phone call to final pickup. The owner's active involvement ensures everything runs smoothly with a touch of personal attention. Customers appreciate receiving their fresh meat just as expected, well packaged in beautiful presentation. It is a go-to place not only for high-quality meats but also for a pleasant dining experience.

Enosburg Meat Market seems to be a local resource with mixed reviews. Some customers appreciated the quality and service, mentioning great burgers and meat packages from honest staff. However, there were issues regarding parking availability, limited selection in the meat case, long wait times when ordering, and problems with order fulfillment such as delayed delivery of smoked meats. The inconsistency in customer service experiences highlights the need for improvements to meet customers' expectations fully.

5th Quarter Butcher Shop is highly praised for its exceptional quality meats and sausages. Customers appreciate the friendly service provided by staff who offer helpful recommendations on cuts and preparation techniques. Located within The Taste Place makes shopping convenient with everything needed in one stop. Regular customers often return due to their favorite cuts of pork being among the best they've had, and having traceability for where their meat comes from allows precise cutting sizes and thicknesses for tailored meals.

Cartiers Meats stands out as the best in town with consistently high praise from customers who love their diverse offerings and superior products. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere and attention to detail, it offers exceptional service that brings back memories of classic customer experiences. Established over seven years ago, Cartiers Meats has maintained a strong reputation based on outstanding reviews and frequent visits by satisfied patrons.

Sharon Beef offers a mix of experiences with some customers praising the service and quality, while others express significant dissatisfaction. The reviews indicate varied levels of satisfaction, from enthusiastic recommendations for professional assistance in handling pig processing to horror stories about rancid meat and unsanitary conditions. There seems to be a fluctuation in standards or management practices, as evidenced by inconsistent ratings, suggesting that customers should carefully consider the specific service provided at any given time.

Backwoods Butcher stands out with its professional service and pristine cleanliness, attributes appreciated by locals who have noticed the family-run business continuing to bring them back. A year ago, their commitment to excellence caught the attention of customers like this one, leading to repeat visits based on a positive experience that extends beyond just the quality of meat products.

Prue's Custom Cutting & Market stands out for its exceptional service and top-notch craftsmanship. Customers rave about Aaron’s dedication to detail and his ability to ensure that their huntspeak products are ready for the journey home. His commitment to customer satisfaction is evident, with him open late in hot weather conditions ensuring everything is prepared meticulously. Not only does he excel in butchery skills, including apple sausage making, but also provides essential services such as ice storage for meat transport. These factors make Prue's a top choice among hunters and animal enthusiasts looking for high-quality processing and thoughtful customer care.

Adam's Wild Game Cutting seemed to handle the processing efficiently, even with an increased demand due to labor shortages. The main issue was that much of the deer meat had an unpleasant smoke odor, affecting both steaks and loins significantly. Given this, there were concerns about potential waste for many customers like the reviewer. However, one satisfied customer noted excellent responsiveness and thoroughness in processing despite the smell issues.