25 Best Butcher Shops in New York (2025 Guide)

Bello Poultry Market stands out with its exceptional variety of food options ranging from freshly made chicken wings to shawarma sandwiches and refreshing juices. The cleanliness is top-notch, with every table and bench being wiped down after each customer. Families appreciate the outdoor seating area where they can enjoy coconuts and hot tea alongside their meals. Additionally, it offers a delightful atmosphere that feels like a vacation resort within the bustling city environment, making it an ideal spot for both casual dining and gathering with loved ones.

Fred the Butcher stands out with its commitment to quality meats at reasonable prices. The variety of offerings includes steaks, pork chops, and ground beef, complemented by excellent deli items and sandwiches. Both indoor and outdoor seating options are available, making it an ideal place for dining in or taking away essentials for meal preparation. Customers appreciate the kind and humble service provided, with some visits including a visit to their bistro for subs and burgers that consistently meet expectations without fail.

Casablanca Meat Market is renowned for its exceptional service and consistently high-quality meats. Located in an easily accessible location near the museum, customers appreciate its cleanliness and adherence to top quality food inspection standards. A testament to this is that it has been a family-owned business for over 75 years, continuing a tradition passed down through generations. Despite closing early, its reputation for freshness and reliability continues to attract both locals and visitors alike.

Triano's Meat Market is highly regarded by its customers for offering a vast selection of meats at fair prices. Known for their friendly and professional staff who are always attentive to customer needs, the store maintains cleanliness and an absence of raw meat odor. Despite some issues with pork exclusivity and occasional service-related concerns, overall experiences highlight consistent quality, delicious offerings, and excellent support from the management team. The establishment's popularity in Rochester is further supported by its ongoing popularity and busy status, making it a preferred choice among locals.

Skip's on the Ridge is highly praised for its extensive selection of meats and other groceries, which customers find superior to larger stores. Known for excellent customer service and fresh, high-quality products, it has become a favorite spot among locals and visitors alike. Despite some initial reservations about being located far from home, this butcher shop managed to impress enough for frequent visits. The friendly staff make every experience memorable, ensuring that everyone is pleased with the selection of meat cuts available there.

Miller's Meat Market offers an extensive selection of meats and seafood, catering to both casual shoppers and those with more specialized needs. Known for their high-quality cuts and exceptional service, customers appreciate the store’s dedication to craftsmanship and attention to detail. Whether it is about preparing favorite recipes or finding unique items like smoked salmon and venison jerky, Miller's consistently delivers satisfaction. Its reputation as a destination for all meat and seafood desires further underscores its value to both regulars and occasional visitors alike.

Hapanowicz Brothers Meat Market stands out with its delightful selection and exceptional quality of meat products. From homemade Polish sausages to the popular mushroom stew and pickled kielbasa, each visit feels like a special treat. The friendly and knowledgeable staff makes customers feel right at home, ensuring every purchase is an enjoyable experience. Despite being located far away from many other options, this market remains a favorite for its excellent service and fresh ingredients, making it worth the journey for those in search of the best meats.

Pettinari's Deli, Pizza & Meats is celebrated for its exceptional meat offerings, from fresh and savory sausages to meticulously prepared sandwiches. Customers praise the quality of meats and the inviting atmosphere that makes every visit enjoyable. Notably, their support for local fire departments through events like raffles adds to the community-mindedness of this establishment. With great service and a variety of menu items at reasonable prices, it stands out as a reliable destination for both casual and special dining experiences.

Dickson's Farmstand Meats is highly regarded for its quality meats and friendly service. Customers appreciate the great hot dogs, delicious burgers, and excellent sandwiches. The atmosphere is welcoming with comfortable seating and options for both indoor dining and takeout. Despite some variations in food quality across items tested, Dickson's consistently delivers top-notch dishes that cater to various palates.

Muncan Food Corporation is renowned for its top-notch Eastern European smoked meats and deli products in New York City. Customers appreciate the wide range of offerings, delicious assortments, fast attentive service, and affordable prices. The friendly staff provides knowledgeable recommendations and ensures customers leave with exactly what they need, contributing to a perfectly run business. Muncan Food Corporation has been a cherished destination for those seeking authentic European flavors and artisanal meats over many years.

Chubs Meats is renowned for its top-notch quality meats and exceptional service. Customers rave about the great deals on bundles available over weekends, along with attentive and helpful staff who go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Whether it's catering or simply purchasing from their butcher shop, everything comes highly recommended; the culture in the store is warm and welcoming, further adding to its appeal. The marinated skirt steak remains a standout item that everyone should try at least once for an unforgettable dining experience.

Prime Time Butcher stands out as one of the most highly rated establishments in Woodbury for its exceptional selection and quality of meats. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable staff who can assist with last-minute requests. The menu includes a variety of dishes, from burgers and chicken to specialty items like stuffed cabbage, all prepared using fresh, high-quality ingredients that meet or exceed expectations set by top restaurants. Whether customers are looking for traditional cuts or innovative creations, Prime Time Butcher consistently delivers satisfying meals that guests can look forward to trying.

Butcher Block stands out as an Irish and British culinary institution, offering a diverse array of meats, sausages, fresh produce, sweets, chocolates, crisps, and hot foods from the deli counter. Its knowledgeable staff ensures that customers find everything they need for meals or treats, including homemade sausages, bacon rolls, and traditional fare like black pudding. The store has been frequented by locals and visitors alike for its quality meats and a wide selection of pantry items, becoming an indispensable part of the community and ensuring that those missing home can easily satisfy their cravings with authentic ingredients.

C & C Meats stands out with its exceptional quality meats and superb prepared foods, earning consistently high praise from customers for their friendly and helpful service. It’s a favorite spot among locals who appreciate the convenience of being able to source top-quality ingredients right in town, making every visit worthwhile. Whether it's for everyday meals or special occasions, C & C Meats offers options that cater to diverse needs, ensuring memorable dining experiences.

Butcher Boys of Monticello stands out with its consistently high-quality meat and fish offerings, earning numerous five-star ratings for their excellent service, quick delivery times, and fresh ingredients. The friendly staff cater to various dietary preferences, offering an extensive selection that caters to different tastes and budgets. Whether customers order online or visit in person, they appreciate the convenience of not having to wait in line at a grocery store, ensuring a smooth shopping experience.

Mazzaferro's Meat & Deli offers an impressive selection with high-quality products and delicious food options. Whether for take-out or dine-in, the wide variety of dishes is always fresh and made to order. The service is noted for its speed and friendliness, especially appreciated when using their catering services. Despite a few recent issues with orders, customers appreciate the overall taste and quality of meats, making it a highly recommended stop, particularly for those not hungry at the time of visit.

Smoke House of the Catskills stands out with its dreamy stop after hiking in the Catskills area, offering top-quality meats, cheeses, and other gourmet items. The establishment has retained the same friendly and professional staff, ensuring customers receive both quality products and excellent service. Recent changes in ownership have not altered the high standards set by previous owners, making it a local gem that continues to attract regulars for its consistent excellence. Whether stocking up or enjoying meals made with their ingredients, Smoke House of the Catskills consistently delights its patrons with its diverse array of delectable meats and other delicacies.

Schaller & Weber is a classic German deli and market that offers an extensive selection of high-quality sausages, cuts of meat, cheese, and German specialties within its compact space. The service remains excellent, with standout pates being a highlight for many visitors. Despite a salty issue with a Reuben sandwich, the store's charm and variety make it worth revisiting, especially for those fond of German delicacies. Their Mozart marzipan chocolates add to the delightful experience, making Schaller & Weber stand out in the culinary scene.

Vincent's Meat Market is renowned for its top-quality meats and exceptional customer service. Customers rave about the great variety of cuts available from different species including exotic options, along with sauces and pastas. Not only do they offer convenience with online ordering and delivery, but their knowledgeable staff goes above and beyond to ensure satisfaction. This establishment has become a staple on Arthur Avenue, earning consistently high ratings across various customer experiences for years.

Imperial Meat Market is highly rated by customers for its consistently fresh meats at reasonable prices. Many patrons appreciate the store’s professional and friendly staff who can accommodate various requests, whether for cutting meat or finding hard-to-find items. Despite one negative review due to deceptive weight claims, Imperial has seen improvements with recent renovations that have enhanced customer satisfaction. The store also caters well beyond its local area, drawing customers from farther regions like Queens, Manhattan, and Staten Island.

Steve's Meats stands out for its exceptional customer service and quality meats. Customers appreciate the friendly staff who take great care to ensure their needs are met, whether they need help choosing from an extensive selection or simply enjoy having knowledgeable assistance throughout their visit. The prices are reasonable, offering fresh meat at a good value. Regulars often return multiple times per month, recommending it as the go-to place for high-quality meats in their area.

Belfiore Meats stands out with its consistent high ratings for quality meats, fresh cold cuts, and excellent customer service across different areas such as soups, olive oils, and specialty items. The store's commitment to freshness is evident in all products, which are always fully stocked and swiftly prepared. Its prime location has made it a beloved go-to spot, even expanding its offerings with the addition of a fish market. Despite minor issues like pricing changes and inconsistent opening hours, Belfiore Meats continues to be cherished for its quality ingredients and welcoming atmosphere.

Rolf's Pork Store is highly esteemed by customers for its exceptional quality meats and German specialty foods. It offers friendly service with knowledgeable staff who can guide buyers on various items. The store has garnered five-star ratings from frequent visitors appreciating both the wide range of products and quick, professional service. Its location makes it easily accessible while ensuring a clean and spotless environment that contributes to its reputation as a top-notch butcher shop in the area.

Esposito Meat Market has stood the test of time since its establishment in 1932. Known for their exceptional quality meats and friendly service, customers appreciate the wide selection including specialty cuts not found elsewhere. The old-school vibe and personalized attention make it a must-visit spot for meat lovers, with many returning patrons who have been enjoying its offerings for years.

Hoelscher Meats Hamburg consistently receives stellar reviews for its fresh and high-quality meats at reasonable prices. Known for impeccable service and friendly staff, customers appreciate the wide variety of options available, from cuts of beef to sausages. Whether it's for everyday purchases or special requests like cutting meat exactly as preferred, this store stands out in offering a welcoming environment with excellent customer care. The experience is further enhanced by social distancing measures in place during regular operations, ensuring both convenience and safety.