2 Best Butcher Shops in Toms River, New Jersey (2025 Guide)

Midshore Meats stands out with its exceptional quality meats and Italian specialties, consistently receiving high praise for both service and offerings from customers who appreciate the old-world charm. The store's reliability is evident in their catering services, which have won accolades for impressing parties with delicious meals tailored to various occasions. Despite some recent negative experiences, the overall reputation of Midshore Meats remains strong among local shoppers for its commitment to quality and dedication to customer satisfaction.

Perrulli's Custom Meats earned top accolades from customers for its sausage, described as the best ever made with no competitors coming close in quality. This four-star review points to truly exceptional flavors and texture that have remained consistent over years of excellence.