2 Best Butcher Shops in Pittsgrove, New Jersey (2025 Guide)

Buck Stop Butcher Shop stands out with its dedication to providing high-quality butchery services year-round. Customers appreciate the professionalism and care given during deer processing, whether they're preparing steaks for sandwiches or burgers for meals. The 24/7 drop-off option adds immense convenience, allowing customers to prepare their venison at any time without worry. Feedback highlights consistent praise for fair pricing, excellent customer service, and a reliable butcher shop that has become a staple in the area, maintaining its reputation as one of the best in San Jose.

M&J is highly praised for their quick turnaround and reasonable pricing, with excellent packaging that even followed special instructions for customer needs. Despite initial concerns about meat yield, they received 15 pounds of deer from someone who dropped off a buck weighing around 100 pounds field-dressed, which was surprisingly generous given the weight difference. The positive reviews highlight their professional service and great customer care, earning them a top rating consistently across various aspects including butchery skills, packaging, and overall satisfaction.