14 Best Butcher Shops in Paterson, New Jersey (2025 Guide)

Brothers Quality Halal Meat stands out with its consistently high-quality meats and excellent service across various reviews. Customers praise the freshness, price competitiveness, friendly staff, and variety of cuts offered. Despite some recent issues regarding weight measurement discrepancies, their overall reputation for delivering great meat at reasonable prices persists. Visiting this store has become a regular preference for customers seeking dependable halal meat in Paterson and beyond.

A & C Pork Store offers an exceptional Italian deli experience with top-notch sandwiches, prime cuts of meat, and homemade mozzarella that's out of this world. The store boasts a wide selection of imported products such as olive oils and macaroni, making it a great place for custom or handmade food orders. Regulars appreciate the clean environment, friendly staff, and reasonable prices for high-quality Italian specialties. Whether you're in search of authentic mozzarella sandwiches or craving freshly made chicken cutlets, A & C Pork Store always delivers exceptional meals to satisfy your taste buds.

Superior Halal Meat Market is highly regarded for its impeccable cleanliness and top-quality meats, with customers praising the freshness and taste of their offerings. Despite some issues reported regarding customer service during rush hours or unusual behavior from staff, the overall quality remains outstanding. This establishment has been around for many years, offering loyal customers a consistent experience, making it the best choice among similar businesses in the area. Customers appreciate its wide range of meats and the commitment to maintaining high standards both in terms of product quality and store hygiene.

Al Hilal Meat & Fish Market has received mixed reviews from customers. It is appreciated for its fresh meat and decent prices, especially for lamb and veal, though some patrons have reported issues with spoiled or incorrect orders. The service can vary; it's praised for being welcoming to customers but also criticized for poor customer interaction at times. Despite occasional frustrations, many still recommend the establishment for their quality meats and fish offerings. However, there are concerns about fresh meat availability and consistent excellent service needed for a top rating.

Medina Custom Halal Meats seems to offer well-organized and diverse options for buying meats including beef, chickens, goats, and live animals. However, there have been mixed experiences with some customers noting issues like unprofessional service, difficulty in getting proper halal slaughtering, dirty environment, and poor customer service. Despite these challenges, the place still receives praise for its clean setup, variety of fresh meat offerings, and good value, especially among long-term regulars.

George the Butcher Inc stands out as one of the best spots in North Jersey for getting quality meat. Customers praise its excellent prices and friendly service, with many returning repeatedly to enjoy their high-quality meats. The store offers unique southern meat options not found elsewhere, ensuring customers always find what they're looking for. Despite a few recent issues with online meat plans, the overall experience remains highly positive among long-term patrons.

Empire Meat Distribution Inc appears to have varied customer experiences with some highlighting poor service and product quality issues, while others found the prices too high or were unsatisfied with the selection of cuts. However, there are also reviews praising the cleanliness, good service, and excellent quality of meats offered by this distributor. Overall, it seems like their reputation fluctuates based on individual interactions and customer preferences.

Halal Butcher Store appears to be highly regarded for its premium quality meats, excellent customer service, efficient delivery, and thoughtful packaging. Customers rave about the amazing taste of their products, with ribeye marbling praised as outstanding. Despite occasional issues with delivery times or product condition, consistent positive reviews highlight the store's commitment to providing top-tier halal meat products to its customers.

Quality Halal Meat Market is a polarizing establishment with some customers giving it one star ratings for rude service and quality issues, while others consistently rate it five stars for its fresh meat and friendly staff. Despite the mixed reviews, there are clear indications that the market offers quality halal meats at competitive prices, making it a popular choice among local shoppers who appreciate their variety of imported goods. However, persistent problems with pricing discrepancies, old or spoiled food, and questionable product authenticity have led some customers to avoid the establishment entirely.

Ramallah Halal Meat Market has received mixed reviews with some customers experiencing issues such as receiving the wrong items and facing theft. However, there are also positive comments about the shop’s welcoming atmosphere, fresh meat, helpful staff, and consistent freshness of products. Despite these challenges, the store maintains a good reputation among many regular customers who appreciate its halal quality and excellent service.

ASM LLC/Past Paradise Halal Meat seems to have mixed reviews with some customers praising the freshness and fairness of prices, along with respectful service. However, there are concerns about inconsistent inventory and sometimes short supplies, quality issues like non-halal meat being sold, and dishonest practices regarding promised quantities or items. The location's opening times also seem to be a point of concern for many visitors who experience delays in service. Despite these issues, there are positive notes suggesting it offers the freshest halal meats at safe prices with honesty.

Al-Aqsa halal meat، ملحمة الأقصى, stands out in the North Jersey area with its commitment to quality meats at great prices, offering an exceptional shopping experience through warm and knowledgeable customer service. The establishment provides an inviting atmosphere and ensures customers receive high-quality halal options that exceed expectations. It has received consistently positive feedback for years, being recommended by satisfied patrons as the best halal meat shop in New Jersey. Notably, customers have praised the expertise of their staff who guide them through selection and preparation, further enhancing the overall experience.

Mennella's Poultry & Meat Marketplace has earned consistent high praise from its customers. Known for offering fresh meats and poultry, the store lets customers have their cuts customized according to preference. The recent move to a new location was greatly appreciated, with feedback noting it is much better than the previous one. Additionally, the prices are highlighted as great value, further cementing Mennella's reputation as a reliable market.

El Habbak stands out as the best establishment in town, according to the review from six years ago. Its excellence is highlighted by the 5-star rating and praise for being the top choice among patrons. The place's quality has been consistently recognized over time, maintaining its status as a go-to destination for many.