13 Best Butcher Shops in Newark, New Jersey (2025 Guide)

Unity Brand Halal Products seems to have a strong reputation among customers who appreciate their wide selection of meats and fresh choices. The store offers excellent service and ensures that the meat remains fresh and flavorful, which has earned it five-star ratings from many. However, there are instances where prices fluctuate significantly, leading some customers to prefer other places instead. Despite these occasional issues, Unity maintains a good standing with its loyal customers who continue to purchase their products due to the consistent quality of their meats and the welcoming atmosphere they provide.

Valley Provisions Inc. is highly praised for its great butcher shop experience with multiple knowledgeable staff members available to assist customers in choosing what they want and providing clear prices that remain consistent over time. The establishment is spotlessly clean and never smells, making it an ideal place for both regular customers and occasional visitors who often travel long distances just to purchase fresh meat. Despite some minor issues like inconsistent product weights or occasional long wait times, the overall service and quality are exceptional, earning consistently high ratings from satisfied patrons over many years.

Broadway Poultry seems to be a place where freshness and quality are top priorities with consistently positive feedback regarding the availability of fresh meat and poultry. Customers appreciate the friendly service and quick delivery times, although there have been instances where customer satisfaction was compromised due to rude staff or poor hygiene conditions. Despite these occasional issues, Broadway Poultry maintains a strong reputation for being a reliable source of locally sourced indigenous foods.

Shorty's Poultry Market seems to be highly rated for its fresh, locally-raised products and excellent service. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, clean premises, and reasonable prices. There are mixed reviews regarding the freshness of chicken deliveries occasionally causing issues, but overall it is considered one of the best poultry markets in the tri-state area with a strong reputation for cleanliness and quality.

Rei da Picanha Meat Market consistently earns high praise for its top-quality meats at very good prices. Customers appreciate the fresh and in-date meat options along with the option to pick their desired cuts right away. The friendly staff ensures an excellent shopping experience, while the cleanliness of the premises further enhances the overall positive impression. Despite one recent issue with raw meat delivery, the numerous 5-star reviews highlight how consistently satisfying this establishment is for those seeking premium meats and service.

115 Meat Market appears to be a highly praised establishment with consistently high ratings from customers. Known for its friendly staff and fresh meats, the store offers excellent service and great customer satisfaction. However, there seems to have been some isolated issues, such as pricing discrepancies and rude behavior at the counter, which impact overall experiences. Despite these minor setbacks, 115 Meat Market remains a reliable source for meat and has earned loyal customers who recommend it based on its quality, fresh produce, and welcoming atmosphere.

Mecca Halal Meats Inc. appears to be a divisive entity based on the mixed reviews received. While some customers praised its meat quality and customer service, others experienced issues with rude employees, poor maintenance of facilities, and unethical treatment of animals. The business also faces challenges related to negative online reviews and concerns about fair pricing, leading many potential customers to question whether they should visit or support this establishment. Despite these criticisms, the company managed to secure a positive reception for Eid- Ul- Adha events, indicating there might be an underlying quality to their services that justifies customer loyalty during other times.

Casa Do Mario seems to offer good meat and seafood with reasonable prices, especially appreciated by those who go early in the morning when lines are shorter. However, there have been issues regarding customer service where long wait times led to frustration for some customers. The reviews also mention occasional staff language barriers, which might cause confusion among non-Portuguese speaking visitors. Despite these minor issues, Casa Do Mario is frequently praised for its fresh meat and excellent service across different visits over the years.

Sonike Halal Place seems to be a satisfactory store with good variety and quality items. While there is room for improvement in speed when packing orders, the store offers various essential products needed by customers. Customers appreciate its selection of African foods. Over time, it has garnered consistently positive feedback across different aspects from satisfied patrons who visited various years ago.

Pão de Açúcar Super Market stands out with its diverse range of products, including Brazilian-specific items found in other supermarkets within Newark's Ironbound district. Despite one male cashier being flirtatious, which made some customers uncomfortable, the overall service remains commendable and friendly. Customers appreciate the good variety available and are impressed by the quality of meat for BBQ purposes, along with the affordable prices for certain products like picaña from Brazil.

Shop & Bag Meat Center appears to be a spot with varying experiences depending on who you ask. Some customers rave about the delicious bacon egg and cheese sandwiches at unbeatable prices, making it their favorite place for breakfast. However, there are also reports of poor service and customer dissatisfaction, especially regarding mishandled orders and rude staff treatment over the phone or in person. The overall impression is mixed—exciting food but inconsistent customer care.

Akwaaba Restaurant & Meat Market seems to offer inconsistent service based on the reviews; one customer had a very negative experience with soggy and cold food, while another mentioned issues with old meat in their stew. However, there are also positive aspects noted by customers like the welcoming service and extensive Caribbean items available for purchase at Akwaaba. The restaurant has received mixed ratings over time, indicating that it might be subject to fluctuations in quality depending on the dish ordered or timing of visit.

Meat Town II showcased good service and competitive pricing with its friendly staff members being highlighted in the review from three years ago. The positive feedback indicates satisfaction in both aspects of quality and customer care at this establishment.