2 Best Butcher Shops in Manasquan, New Jersey (2025 Guide)

Mr. Prime Old Tyme Butcher stands out as a hidden gem in the community, offering premium cuts of meat with exceptional quality and craftsmanship passed down through generations. The family-owned establishment delights customers with its exceptional service, attention to detail, and wide selection of meats, from dry-aged steaks to specialty products like Bell & Evans chicken breasts. Its reputation has grown steadily over the years, earning multiple 5-star reviews for everything from perfectly seasoned butchers blocks to fresh-baked bread and signature dishes. Customers frequently mention how genuinely friendly and passionate its owners are about their craft, making each visit feel like a return to an era when businesses treated customers with warmth and care.