2 Best Butcher Shops in Edwardsville, Illinois (2025 Guide)

Bagley Farms Meat Market has earned consistently high praise for its excellent quality meats and exceptional customer service. Customers appreciate the wide selection, affordable prices, and knowledgeable staff who are always ready to assist in finding just the right cut of meat. The store maintains an inviting atmosphere with fresh presentation, clean environment, and friendly interactions that make every visit enjoyable. Despite occasional negative experiences reported, Bagley Farms continues to be a preferred choice for many shoppers seeking top-notch meats.

1818 Butcher + Market seems to be a place with varying experiences based on different visits. Some customers appreciated the quality of meat and thoughtfully prepared food, earning multiple 5-star ratings for dishes like the Blackberries and Brie sandwich or elevated dining experiences. However, others faced issues such as stale buns, misleading expectations about menu items, and unexpected mistakes in their orders. Despite these challenges, there are still consistent positive reviews praising friendly staff and excellent service, indicating that 1818 Butcher + Market has potential to be a standout culinary destination with room for improvement.