2 Best Butcher Shops in San Mateo, California (2025 Guide)

El Toro Meat Market seems to offer a mixed experience with both positive and negative reviews. The quality of meat sometimes varies; some customers found their orders hard and dry, while others had delicious experiences. Prices are competitive, but the store might have parking issues. Service can be inconsistent with varying levels of customer care from different staff members, leading to mixed feelings among customers. Despite these challenges, it retains a good reputation for fresh produce and meat, especially in terms of fruits and vegetables, as well as some specific items like pork carnitas and liver.

Cooper Bellissimo’s Artisanal Salami House is recognized as the pinnacle of artisanal salami craftsmanship in San Mateo. The store’s wide array of over 100 different types of salami caught the eye and impressed many, with a particular mention for the exclusive Landrace pigs sourced from Italy. Despite lacking restrooms, patrons appreciated Cooper Bellissimo’s knowledgeable staff who provided extensive information about various salami varieties, making it an unforgettable experience that left customers eager to return.